Gostou do Conteúdo - Seja um Seguidor do Blog do Professor Ari

sábado, 21 de novembro de 2026

Restructuring Advantage: Action Before the Crisis, The importance of the Business Restructuring Plan

SIGHTS

Turnaround • EBITDA • Cash Flow • Valuation • M&A

The Restructuring Advantage: Act Before the Crisis

How to Restore Performance, Preserve Value, and Prepare a Company for Its Next Chapter
By Professor Ari — Ariovaldo Lopes da Silva | Master’s Degree in Accounting and Finance
DiagnoseAddress root causes, not just symptoms
RecoverMargins, cash flow, and productivity
Create ValueStrategic readiness and M&A preparation

How to Restore Performance, Preserve Value, and Prepare a Company for Its Next Chapter

Introduction — It Is Better to Contain the Smoke Than Fight the Fire

Managing a company in distress can be compared to fighting a fire.

When the fire is still small, many options remain available. Management can identify its source, eliminate the causes, protect assets, and prevent it from spreading.

Once the flames have grown, however, the options narrow dramatically. Costs rise, decisions must be made under pressure, and the objective often shifts from preventing damage to simply limiting losses.

Much the same happens in business.

Companies rarely enter a severe crisis overnight. Warning signs usually emerge much earlier:

  • steadily declining margins;
  • operating expenses growing faster than revenue;
  • weakening cash generation;
  • excessive inventories;
  • rising working-capital requirements;
  • productivity below expectations;
  • disproportionately heavy administrative structures;
  • loss of customers or market share;
  • increasing indebtedness;
  • investments earning inadequate returns;
  • inefficient processes;
  • persistently declining profitability.

Viewed individually, some of these indicators may seem manageable.

When several appear at the same time—and particularly when they become a trend—they send an important warning signal.

That is precisely when a Business Restructuring Plan should come into play.

1. Restructuring Should Not Be Synonymous with Corporate Failure

There is a widespread misconception that business restructuring is appropriate only when a company is approaching a serious financial crisis.

That is simply not true.

Large corporate groups and multinationals regularly review business units, subsidiaries, factories, products, and markets to identify operations performing below expectations.

An operation may be profitable and still require restructuring.

Why?

Because its return may fall below its cost of capital, its margins may be deteriorating, or its organizational structure may no longer fit current market conditions.

In this sense, restructuring is also a preventive management tool.

The earlier the problems are identified, the more strategic options management will have.

2. Today's Business Environment Makes the Discussion Even More Relevant

In Brazil, we frequently see reports of companies facing financial difficulties, debt renegotiations, court-supervised reorganization, plant closures, asset disposals, and workforce-reduction programs.

Each case is different. Without a detailed understanding of the circumstances, it would be inappropriate to assume that these businesses failed to consider restructuring at an earlier stage.

The important question is different:

How many companies could expand their range of options by identifying and addressing deteriorating performance indicators long before reaching a critical financial situation?

That is the central issue.

Judicial reorganization has a legitimate role within the legal and economic system. From a management perspective, however, there is an enormous difference between restructuring while multiple strategic alternatives remain available and attempting recovery after cash, credit, and stakeholder confidence have already been seriously impaired.

Returning to our opening metaphor:

It is far easier to extinguish a small fire than to fight an entire building engulfed in flames.

3. What Is a Business Restructuring Plan?

A Business Restructuring Plan is a structured initiative to review the business thoroughly and implement measures capable of restoring competitiveness, profitability, cash generation, and economic value.

One distinction is essential:

Restructuring does not simply mean cutting costs.

A sound program can address several dimensions of the organization at once.

Strategy

Review of the business model, markets, products, customers, distribution channels, competitive positioning, and investments.

Operations

Productivity, installed capacity, manufacturing efficiency, quality, logistics, inventory, procurement, maintenance, technology, and processes.

Organizational Structure

Management layers, accountability, overlaps, centralization or decentralization of activities, and workforce sizing.

Finance

Working capital, debt, cash generation, investments, idle assets, financing costs, and capital structure.

Profitability

Margin analysis by product, customer, business unit, distribution channel, and market.

Expenses

Review of administrative, selling, and operating expenses, focusing on costs that have accumulated over time without creating proportional value.

Portfolio

Products, customers, or business activities may consume significant resources while generating inadequate returns.

In certain circumstances, selling, discontinuing, or redesigning part of the business can create more value than simply trying to increase sales.

4. Diagnosis Must Come Before Headcount Reductions

A fairly common mistake in restructuring programs is to begin immediately with workforce reductions.

Can they be necessary? Of course.

But they should not automatically be the first question.

Before making cuts, management must understand the underlying problems.

A sound restructuring diagnosis should answer questions such as:

  • Where does the company actually make money?
  • Where does it destroy value?
  • Which products generate the strongest margins?
  • Which customers make a genuine contribution?
  • How much cash is tied up in inventory?
  • How productive are the key processes?
  • Are there idle or underutilized assets?
  • Have expenses grown faster than sales?
  • Is the organizational structure appropriate for the company's present size?
  • Which processes could be automated?
  • Which activities add no value?
  • Which investments could be deferred?
  • Where are the main cash leakages?
  • What is the organization's true EBITDA potential?

Only after a thorough diagnosis should management build its action plan.

5. Restructuring and Value Creation

This dimension is particularly important for businesses seeking investors, considering a merger or acquisition, or preparing for a future sale.

Imagine two similar companies.

The first has declining earnings, rising expenses, and no structured plan to address the situation.

The second faces comparable difficulties but can present investors with:

  • a detailed diagnosis;
  • clearly defined initiatives;
  • accountable owners;
  • an implementation schedule;
  • expense-reduction targets;
  • productivity targets;
  • cash-flow projections;
  • expected margin improvements;
  • monthly performance indicators.

Both companies may report similar results today.

Yet investors are likely to view them very differently.

That is because a company's value depends not only on current earnings, but above all on expectations regarding its future ability to generate cash.

6. When the Market Believes in the Plan

Many years ago, I had an interesting experience as a small individual investor.

A publicly traded company announced a major restructuring program after the market closed.

After reviewing the information released, I concluded that the measures could significantly improve its future performance, and I decided to buy a small position.

Over the following periods, the shares appreciated substantially.

Naturally, this isolated experience does not establish that every restructuring announcement will lead to a higher share price—much less an immediate increase.

The lesson was different:

When investors consider a restructuring plan credible, achievable, and capable of improving future cash flows, the market's perception of the company's value may change rapidly.

Markets do not value yesterday's earnings alone.

They price expectations about tomorrow.

7. Restructuring Before Selling a Company

This principle becomes even more relevant when shareholders plan to sell a business.

Consider a company with:

Stable revenue + rising expenses + falling margins = deteriorating EBITDA.

If that company is put up for sale under these conditions, a prospective buyer is likely to reflect those weaknesses in its valuation.

The buyer may also apply an additional risk discount and factor in part of the restructuring costs it expects to incur after the acquisition.

Now consider a different scenario.

The company begins implementing a Business Restructuring Plan ahead of the sale and starts demonstrating:

Controlled expenses + higher productivity + recovering margins + improving cash flow = recovering EBITDA.

The buyer is now assessing a different trajectory.

That can materially affect perceived risk and, consequently, the value assigned to the business.

For this reason, in certain M&A transactions, restructuring before a sale can be a powerful shareholder value-creation strategy.

8. Restructuring Costs — The Cost of Transformation

Restructuring initiatives also involve costs.

These may include:

  • severance and employee termination costs;
  • plant or site closures and consolidation;
  • contract termination costs;
  • relocation of operations;
  • specialist advisory fees;
  • process redesign;
  • impairment of certain assets;
  • costs related to implementing the restructuring program.

In management reporting and communications with investors, companies often separately identify certain effects considered non-recurring, using adjusted measures, for example.

This is where terms such as Reported EBITDA and Adjusted EBITDA come into the discussion.

There is, however, a crucial point:

Classifying an item as a “restructuring cost” does not make the expense disappear from the financial statements.

Financial reporting remains subject to the applicable accounting standards.

Adjusted performance measures should be transparent and consistent, enabling investors to reconcile reported accounting results with the metrics presented by management.

9. What About Restructuring Provisions?

This is another particularly important issue.

Under IFRS, the principal standard covering restructuring provisions is IAS 37 — Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets.

In simple terms, a company cannot merely decide at year-end:

“We intend to spend a certain amount on restructuring next year, so let's recognize the entire provision now.”

There are criteria that must be met.

Recognition of a restructuring provision requires a present obligation that satisfies IAS 37. In the restructuring context, this generally entails a sufficiently detailed formal plan and a valid expectation created among those affected that the restructuring will be carried out.

This distinction is essential because it prevents provisions from being used indiscriminately to shift earnings between reporting periods.

Therefore:

Planning a restructuring is a management decision.

Recognizing a restructuring provision requires compliance with accounting recognition criteria.

The two concepts are related, but they are not the same.

10. The Meaning of “Below the Line”

In international corporate environments, the expression below the line is often used informally in internal performance analysis to describe exceptional, unusual, or non-recurring items.

From a management standpoint, the distinction can be useful.

The objective is to help executives, shareholders, and investors understand:

  1. how the recurring business performed; and
  2. which effects relate to specific transformation or restructuring events.

But transparency is essential here as well.

A management-reporting classification does not override the recognition and presentation requirements of IFRS or applicable local accounting standards.

Readers should be able to reconcile the reported accounting result to any adjusted indicator presented by management.

11. A Sound Plan Must Turn Intentions into Numbers

A Business Restructuring Plan should not end as a PowerPoint presentation.

It should translate into measurable objectives.

For example:

Current situation → Action → Target → Accountable owner → Deadline → EBITDA impact → Cash impact

Each initiative must have an owner, a timeline, and an expected financial outcome.

Most importantly, actual results must be monitored at regular intervals.

Without that discipline, a so-called restructuring plan risks becoming little more than a collection of good intentions.

12. Restructuring Is Not Destruction. It Is Rebuilding.

This may be the most important concept in the entire article.

There is a strong tendency to associate restructuring with layoffs.

But a genuine business restructuring should pursue a far broader objective:

Eliminate what destroys value and strengthen what creates it.

Sometimes a leaner organizational structure will be necessary.

In other situations, the answer may lie in automation, process redesign, renegotiating contracts, exiting unprofitable products, improving pricing, reducing inventories, raising productivity, or focusing resources on the most profitable activities.

The ultimate goal is not simply to make the business smaller.

It is to make it better.

Conclusion — Do Not Wait for the Fire

Companies rarely fall into serious distress without issuing earlier warning signs.

Margins decline.

Expenses rise.

Inventories grow.

Cash balances shrink.

Debt increases.

Productivity deteriorates.

The difficulty is that these indicators are often assessed separately and treated as temporary setbacks.

Until they are no longer temporary.

A Business Restructuring Plan should begin before that point.

It should not be viewed solely as a tool for businesses nearing insolvency, but as a powerful means of managing performance, restoring profitability, and creating value.

This matters even more when shareholders are preparing a company to attract investment or enter an M&A process.

A company facing difficulties without a plan represents uncertainty.

A company with clearly diagnosed problems, actions already underway, measurable targets, and early evidence of progress tells a very different story.

Investors do not buy companies alone.

They buy prospects for future value creation.

Perhaps the most important question for a business owner, therefore, is not:

“Does my company need restructuring?”

It may be:

“If some of our most important indicators are deteriorating, why wait until the situation becomes a full-blown fire?”

References and Further Reading

INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (IASB). IAS 37 — Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets. London: IFRS Foundation.

INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (IASB). IAS 36 — Impairment of Assets. London: IFRS Foundation.

INTERNATIONAL ACCOUNTING STANDARDS BOARD (IASB). IFRS 5 — Non-current Assets Held for Sale and Discontinued Operations. London: IFRS Foundation.

PORTER, Michael E. Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. New York: Free Press, 1980.

KAPLAN, Robert S.; NORTON, David P. The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1996.

DAMODARAN, Aswath. Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset. Hoboken: Wiley.

KOLLER, Tim; GOEDHART, Marc; WESSELS, David. Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies. Hoboken: Wiley.

Important Note

This article is intended for educational and management purposes. Accounting, corporate, tax, and legal aspects of restructuring must be evaluated in light of each organization's circumstances and the applicable standards and regulations.

Nenhum comentário:

Postar um comentário